Donald Trump Faces Prospect of Fifth Indictment

Donald Trump Faces Prospect of Fifth Indictment
Story by Kate Plummer  •
12/22/23

Republican presidential candidate and former U.S. President Donald Trump gestures as he wraps up a campaign event on December 19, 2023 in Waterloo, Iowa. A leaked recording claimed the former president pressured Michigan election officials to overturn the result of the 2020 election.
Republican presidential candidate and former U.S. President Donald Trump gestures as he wraps up a campaign event on December 19, 2023 in Waterloo, Iowa. A leaked recording claimed the former president pressured Michigan election officials to overturn the result of the 2020 election.
© Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images
Donald Trump could be facing a fifth criminal indictment following reports he pressured Michigan election figures to overturn the result of the 2020 election.

According to The Detroit News, citing a leaked recording of a phone call by someone the publication said was present for the conversation, Trump personally pressured two Republican members of the Wayne County Board of Canvassers, Monica Palmer and William Hartmann, not to sign the certification of the election results in the state, which Biden won by 154,000 votes. It reports Ronna McDaniel, chair of the Republican National Committee, was also involved in the call.

Current Time 0:21
/
Duration 1:03
Newsweek
Will Donald Trump Face Bribery Charges? What We Know
0
View on Watch
View on Watch
Newsweek contacted representatives for Trump by email and McDaniel by social media to comment on this story. Newsweek has been unable to independently verify the recording. The Detroit News reported that spokespeople for Palmer, McDaniel and Trump did not dispute a summary of the call. Hartmann died in 2021.
Wake Forest Counseling Degree - Start Your Counseling Career
Wake Forest Counseling Degree - Start Your Counseling Career
Ad
Wake Forest University
The former president and GOP frontrunner is facing a federal case brought by special counsel Jack Smith alleging he worked to overturn the results of the election, won by President Joe Biden. Trump, who has denied any wrongdoing, has been charged with conspiring to defraud the United States, conspiring to obstruct an official proceeding, obstructing a congressional proceeding and conspiracy against rights.

While the recording has been described by attorney Joe Gallina as "perfect evidence" against the former president and "another smoking gun" in the federal trial, other commentators have speculated that the evidence could be grounds for a fifth criminal indictment on bribery charges.

Anthony Michael Kreis, a law professor and political scientist at Georgia State University College of Law, wrote on X, formerly Twitter, that Trump could face "a fifth set of charges" because offering a lawyer could be considered a bribe under the Michigan Penal Code, which is a felony.

The recording alleged McDaniel said: "If you can go home tonight, do not sign it... We will get you attorneys."

Trump reportedly added: "We'll take care of that."

Alongside an extract of the code, Kreis wrote: "It seems like Ronna McDaniel could be in some trouble in Michigan and Donald Trump may be facing a fifth set of charges. A promise was offered in exchange for an official act unlike in Georgia where the preferred method appears to have been limited to browbeating state officials."


Ian Bassin, a former associate White House counsel, said: "My guess is the Michigan attorney general is reviewing the statute of limitations on Michigan Code Section 750.118."

Section 750.118 of the Michigan Penal Code says executives who accept or offer a gift "or to do any act beneficial to such officer" with an understanding that "his vote, opinion or judgement shall be given in any particular matter" must forfeit his office, be disqualified for holding any other public office and could face a prison sentence of up to 10 years of a fine of up to $5,000.


Meanwhile, former U.S. Attorney Joyce Vance said: "Offering an official something of value (services of a lawyer) in exchange for withholding official action (certifying the Wayne County vote) sounds like a classic case of bribery under Michigan State law."

However, Mark Shanahan, an associate professor in politics at the University of Surrey in the U.K., said that while a Michigan indictment "may make judicial sense," further charges against Trump could help his campaign.

"Anyone looking to bring more charges against Donald Trump needs to be aware of the fine balance at play," he told Newsweek. "Of course, when there is clear evidence that a crime has been committed, the perpetrator should be brought to justice. But is such a febrile political environment, any DA needs to consider both timing and impact of further charges against the former president.

"Each time the courts seek to rein Trump in, his polling numbers rise and money floods into his campaign—the Colorado Supreme Court has given him a tremendous Christmas present. And each new set of charges enables him to double down on his victim story and press harder on the story he's peddling on the politicization of justice. While an indictment out of Michigan may make judicial sense, if it happens in the coming weeks, it may simply give more ammunition to the Trump campaign to dismiss it as a political pile-in and in so doing, boost the chances of a second Trump presidential term."

Steven Cheung, a Trump campaign spokesperson, told The Detroit News Trump's actions "were taken in furtherance of his duty as president of the United States to faithfully take care of the laws and ensure election integrity, including investigating the rigged and stolen 2020 presidential election."

"President Trump and the American people have the constitutional right to free and fair elections," Cheung said.

In his four criminal indictments, the GOP frontrunner is facing a total of 91 felony charges—two involving alleged efforts to overturn the results of the 2020 election, one regarding the alleged mishandling of classified documents that he retained when he left the White House, and one regarding hush money payments to former adult film star Stormy Daniels. Trump has denied any wrongdoing in all of his cases.

Related Articles

Donald Trump Michigan Tape Is 'Perfect Evidence'—Attorney
Ronna McDaniel May Be in Big Trouble
Donald Trump's Five Words on Phone Call That Could Doom Him
Start your unlimited Newsweek trial

***
Michigan election chief sounds off dire warning about Trump after audio of pressure effort

Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
© provided by RawStory
Following the report that former President Donald Trump tried to pressure canvassers in Michigan to block certification of election results, Michigan Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson wrote a dire warning about the threat the former president still poses in The Daily Beast.

"For me, the lowest moment in the post-election battle to protect Michigan’s accurate and legitimate election results in 2020 was not when armed protestors stormed my home," wrote Benson. "It wasn’t when a gathering of Trump supporters showed up to Michigan’s State Capitol demanding to be let in as the state’s 'true slate of electors' when we all were sheltered in the State Senate Chambers finalizing the electoral college. It wasn’t even when Rudy Giuliani came to town to headline a sham legislative hearing filled with lies about our elections. No, the most challenging time for me was the night of the Wayne County Board of Canvassers meeting."

She continued:

POLL: Should Trump be allowed to run for office?

"I distinctly remember coming home that evening feeling completely defeated," wrote Benson. "We knew about the pressure on the two members of the Board not to certify. We were prepared to go to court to ensure certification at the local and state level — and we were confident we’d win. But blocking certification in Wayne County and pushing this to the courts was part of a bigger plan to delay the process and foster doubt and uncertainty that would enable the Trump campaign to push Pennsylvania, which was certifying the next week, to delay as well. After that, we knew other dominos would fall — Georgia, Wisconsin, maybe even New Mexico."

ALSO READ: A neuroscientist’s guide to surviving Christmas with Trump-loving relatives

Michigan was an epicenter of efforts by the former president to block the election results. Earlier this year, the fake electors declared for Trump in the state were indicted on felony charges.

Related video: Tape reveals Donald Trump pressured Wayne County officials not to certify 2020 vote, a new report says (WXYZ Detroit 7, MI)
New this morning reports revealing a conversation where former President
WXYZ Detroit 7, MI
Tape reveals Donald Trump pressured Wayne County officials not to certify 2020 vote, a new report says
0
View on Watch
View on Watch
Ultimately, Trump's efforts to block the vote failed in the state, and President Joe Biden's win was certified — but it is important that everyone be "ready" for what Trump might be planning next, Benson concluded.

"We learned our lessons from 2020. Our successes in 2022 were clear proof that we have a strategy, too: making sure every citizen’s voice is heard and every vote is counted," she wrote. "As we head into 2024, we will be on the alert in every precinct and every district across the state, empowering every citizen with the truth and facts they need to have confidence in their vote, their voice, and our elections. And no matter what we face, I know we will ensure that an attempt like Trump’s in 2020 to overturn an election will never succeed."

Read the piece here.

Recommended Links:
;Leaked recording reveals Michigan Trump ally ranting about 'civil war' after fake elector wife is indicted

;Leaked recording reveals Michigan Trump ally ranting about 'civil war' after fake elector wife is indicted

;Trump shares warning that his own re-election will plunge America into dictatorship

;Auto workers warned Trump to keep his distance: report

;Could Trump face state charges for election lies? Michigan supreme court justice wonders