MAGA s Us-Versus-Them

Is MAGA’s ‘Us-Versus-Them’ Rhetoric Fueling Polarization? Examining 25 Ways MAGA Supporters Are Shaping the GOP’s Direction
Story by Amy Harris •
09/23/23

Is MAGA’s ‘Us-Versus-Them’ Rhetoric Fueling Polarization? Examining 25 Ways MAGA Supporters Are Shaping the GOP’s Direction
Pride in Being a Considerate Neighbor
Undermining Traditional Conservatism
Embracing Conspiracy Theories

The rise of the “Make America Great Again” (MAGA) movement has significantly influenced the direction of the Republican Party. While some view it as a return to core conservative values, critics argue that MAGA supporters are negatively impacting the GOP. Here are 25 ways they believe this faction is ruining the party.

2
Encouraging Polarization
© Shutterstock / Krakenimages.com
MAGA’s us-versus-them rhetoric might be driving increased polarization, making bipartisan cooperation more challenging.

Undermining Traditional Conservatism
©mage Credit: Shutterstock / Vitezslav Vylicil
By shifting focus to populism, some feel that MAGA is eroding the GOP’s traditional conservative principles.
4
Embracing Conspiracy Theories
©Image Credit: Shutterstock / CLS Digital Arts
Support for unfounded conspiracy theories can damage the party’s credibility and relationships with allies.

5
Alienating Moderate Voters
©Image Credit: Shutterstock / Sergey Tinyakov
The movement’s extreme stances may deter moderate voters, limiting the party’s appeal.

Failing to Condemn Extremism
© Shutterstock / ViDI Studio
A perceived failure to distance itself from extremist groups may harm the GOP’s reputation.

Rejecting Expert Opinions
©Image Credit: Shutterstock / RealPeopleStudio
Ignoring expertise in fields like science and economics can undermine policy effectiveness and credibility.

Focusing on Personality Over Policy
© Shutterstock / create jobs 51
Emphasizing loyalty to individuals rather than policy may hinder the party’s ability to develop coherent platforms.

9
Damaging International Relationships
©Image Credit: Shutterstock / Ground Picture
MAGA’s nationalistic approach could strain relationships with long-standing international allies.

10
Inhibiting Party Unity
©Image Credit: Shutterstock / manpeppe
Internal divisions created by MAGA might weaken the GOP’s ability to act as a unified front.